| 2008 Primary Re-hash |
Home |
I lost the August 5, 2008 Democratic primary.
Incumbent Joan Bauer got 5,277
votes and I got 571, about 10% of the Democratic vote. Even though there were no
contested races on the Republican side of the ballot, 68th district Republican
candidate David Irons got 1,551 votes. I apparently failed in my attempt to get
Republicans to vote on the Democratic side.
About the only campaigning I did was an
11x5.5" postcard mailed to all 18,423 households in which someone voted in the 2006
general election. It was sent late, arriving in mailboxes the Friday, Saturday
and Monday before the election. That was a big mistake. I forgot about absentee voters.
3,457 Lansing residents voted by mail, and we can assume that very few got my postcard
before they filled out their ballot.
But that was not my only mistake. The
68th district includes most, but not all, of the city of Lansing. It
also includes all of Lansing Township, a separate, self-governing
entity. I got my voter list from the Lansing City Clerk, so none of my
postcards went to Lansing Township voters. 985 of them voted in the
primary.
And then there was the Post Office's
mistake. I received a call from the Post Office on August 14 saying that
423 of my postcards didn't get sent. (The Post Office is going to refund
$84 in postage.)
The total number of votes cast in the
primary for 68th district representative was 7399. The total number of
voters who voted without having seen my postcard was 4865:
| 3457 |
absentee voters in
Lansing |
| 985 |
Lansing Township
residents |
|
423 |
postcards lost in the
Post Office |
| 4865 |
voters who did not
see postcard |
That leaves 2534 (7399 minus 4865) who
did get the postcard. Since 21% of all votes cast in the primary
went to the Republican, we can assume that 21% of the people who got my
postcard voted Republican and 79% voted Democrat. 79% of 2534 is 2002.
So of the 2002 Democratic voters who got my card, 28% (581) voted for
me. 28% sounds a lot better than 10%. Not so bad for a Democrat who is
against unions and for taxing seniors. At the start of the campaign,
Mark Grebner, a local political expert, said I would be doing very well
to get 20% of the Democratic vote.
My campaign was essentially one-man
operation. I was the campaign manager and campaign treasurer. I created
the website and provided the text for the postcard. A friend who knows
Microsoft Excel showed me how to eliminate the “duplicates” (extra
voters in the same household) from the voter list I got from the Lansing
City Clerk. A guy at the printers took my basic design for the postcard and added the
color. The picture on the postcard was cropped from a photo taken 3
years ago for my wife Carol’s parish directory.
It is not too late to donate to my campaign.
When I started, I promised Carol that I wouldn't spend any of our own
money, but I ended up "loaning" the campaign $6,600.
The Lansing City Pulse Did Me Wrong
On July 9,
Derek Wallbank of the Lansing State Journal came over to the house and
interviewed me for about 45 minutes. Wallbank's article appeared July 16, and I thought it was accurate and
fair:
State Rep. Joan Bauer and Steve
Harry are a bit like oil and vinegar politically. Harry, a retired
procedures analyst living in west Lansing, thinks unions are
destroying Michigan's economy. He wants to tax pensions, eliminate
the sales tax, abolish the lottery and get rid of the state Senate.
"I think the economy will take care of itself if we can do away with
unions and fix the business tax," Harry, 65, said . . .
Despite their differences, both
Bauer and Harry support abortion rights for women and would seek to
reverse a 2004 constitutional amendment that banned gay marriage.
They also agreed that Michigan must find a way to increase funding
for schools and roads. Harry would pay for it through a tax increase
while Bauer said she would designate part of the sales tax collected
on gasoline for road and bridge repairs.
The Lansing State Journal didn't do
endorsements for the primary election. The weekly City Pulse did, although no
one from the Pulse took the time to talk to me. The Pulse's article appeared July
30, the Wednesday before the election:
Lansing freshman Rep. Joan Bauer’s
lone opponent in the Democratic primary, Steve Harry, is a former
state employee who claims the state still owes him $6 million. Not
your typical Democrat, Steve Harry, of Lansing, wants to “drive the
unions out of Michigan,” repeal the prevailing wage law and shut
down the Lottery. Harry also says “seniors enjoy a huge income tax
break” and that both the Parole Board and the Liquor Control
Commission should be abolished.
The merits of some of Harry’s
positions could make for some lively dinner table debate. In the
meantime, Bauer has positioned herself on the House committee in
charge of spending state money and could be in line to chairing the
community colleges budget next term. She’s leading the effort to get
more state money to reimburse the fire departments in Lansing and
East Lansing for the costs of providing servicing state buildings
and Michigan State University.
It seems the main reason for the
Pulse's endorsement of Joan Bauer was that she was the incumbent. But what
really what made my blood boil was their statement that I claim the
state still owes me $6 million. It made me sound like a crackpot. And since
the Pulse is a weekly, they could issue no correction before the August
5 primary. I immediately fired off an email to the Pulse. The title was "Stab in the
Back":
You really did a job on me in your
July 30 primary guide. Is it because I declined to buy an ad? You
said that I was “a former state employee who claims the state still
owes him $6 million.” “Michigan Owes Me $6 Million” is the title of
a story I wrote about my experiences at the Department of Social
Services in the 1970s. I tell how I persuaded Social Services
management to undertake an effort to automate the welfare allowance
update process and then did most of the program design. It saved the
state $5 million in the first year. (It would have saved $6 million
if they had listened sooner.) Nowhere in the account do I claim the
state owes me anything, and I never have claimed that. It was only
the title of the story, and it was a joke. The story is on my
personal website, not my campaign website.
I got the idea for the title to my
story from a 1963 book by Bob Hope called "I Owe Russia $1200".
The next day, July 31, there was this
exchange of emails between me and Pulse editor/publisher Berl Schwartz:
Your decision on advertising has
nothing to do with it. I will look into your statement about the $6
million and get back to you.
Thank you.
Berl Schwartz
Berl,
Actually, I never believed my decision on advertising influenced
your reporter. It was just lazy reporting. And maybe a little
mean-spirited.
Steve
Thanks. I'm told the reference came
from your Web site, but when I went there, I didn't see a "story,"
as you called it in your e-mail. I did see a letter. Is that what
you meant when you said story? I'm just trying to get to the bottom
of this.
Berl
It is on my
personal website, www.steveharryssite.com. There is a link at the
lower left to "Michigan Owes Me $6 Million". Evenually, you'll get
to an intro followed by a list of chapter titles. Click on "$6
Million."
Steve
Then on Saturday,
August 2:
Steve: Not to
belabor this, but what was the purpose of the letter on your
political Web site that comes up when you click on The State Owes Me
Six Million?
Berl,
I'm afraid I don't know what you are talking about. I don't think
"The State Owes Me $6 Million" appears on my political website (steveharryforstaterep.org).
"Michigan Owes Me $6 Million" appears on my personal website (steveharryssite.com).
Is the letter you are referring to the one I link to in the
introduction to the story, in the sentence "A letter I wrote in June
1976 contains a summary of my career at Social Services"?
Call me at 323-3897 and maybe we can straighten this out.
Steve
And on August 3:
what are the new
addresses of the two sites?
Berl,
There are no new addresses. My campaign site is
www.steveharryforstaterep.org. My personal site is
www.steveharryssite.com. These have always been the addresses.
Steve
That was the end of
the email exchange. The City Pulse never did print my July 30 email,
which was sent to the address they give for letters to the editor, and
I've heard nothing more from Berl.
When I realized on
July 30 that the City Pulse could not correct before the election their characterization of
me as "“a former state employee who claims the state still owes him $6
million”, I emailed a letter to the State Journal
that was similar to the one I sent to the Pulse:
The City Pulse
really did a job on me in the July 30 primary guide. They said I was
“a former state employee who claims the state still owes him $6
million.” They are referring to a story I wrote about my experiences
at the Department of Social Services in the 1970s. It tells how I
persuaded Social Services management to undertake an effort to
automate the welfare allowance update process, and then did most of
the program design myself. It saved the state $5 million in the
first year. (It would have saved $6 million had management acted
sooner.) The title of the story, “Michigan Owes Me $6 Million”, was
a joke. Nowhere in the account do I claim the state owes me
anything, and I never have claimed that. The story is on my personal
website (steveharryssite.com), not my campaign website (steveharryforstaterep.org).
No one from the City Pulse talked to me except to solicit a campaign
ad, which I declined.
My thinking was that
being a daily, the Journal could print it before the election. They
never did print it. |